Fountains’ financial problems in the second half
of the thirteenth century were partly caused by external factors,
such as war, famine, taxation and disease. However, Fountains was in many
ways the
architect of its own downfall. By engaging in advance wool sales,
a practice that was widespread despite its prohibition by the General
Chapter,
the
community landed itself in considerable debt. Wool was the chief
cash crop of Fountains – as indeed of other Cistercian abbeys in the
North of England – and the community was a leading exporter to Flanders
and Italy. By pledging its wool to foreign merchants in return for large
sums
of money, Fountains played with fire and had to face the consequences
when these estimated quotas could not be met. By 1274 the abbey’s
financial situation was so serious that Fountains was taken into royal receivership.
The community recovered within a couple of years, but soon returned
to its
old ways, pledging all its goods, including the abbey, as surety
for its wool. In 1291 Fountains had debts amounting to almost £7000
and the abbey was once again taken into royal receivership.
Medieval intelligence
In September 1300 Edward
I instructed the abbots of Fountains, Jervaulx and St Mary’s,
York, as well as the dean and chapter of York Minster to trawl the
chronicles
and archives of their houses for historical material relating to Scotland;
the best-informed member of each community to report these findings
at the next parliament.
[Memorials of Fountains I, p. 140]
Fountains’ situation
was not simply of its own making. Excessive financial demands from
the Crown, the Order and the Church, as well as adverse weather
conditions, cattle diseases and warfare, all contributed to the
community’s
plight. These problems were neither peculiar to Fountains, nor
to the Cistercians, but affected the country at large and in some
cases Europe. However, Fountains’ ability
to bounce back time and again and to resume its role as a leading
power in the religious, ecclesiastic and political life of the
country, was rather
exceptional. Religious communities in the North of England were
particularly troubled by the Scots and their fight for independence.
The Scots’ victory
over the English at the Battle of Bannockburn in 1314, meant that
the North of England now lay open to invasion. Fountains was directly
hit in 1318
when it was occupied by the marauders; the following year the abbey’s
home estates were pillaged. Troubles in the North had prompted
the king to request a loan of 200 marks from Fountains in August
1313 – the
community offered at least 40 marks. In 1318 and 1321/22 the abbot
of Fountains, as one holding lands beyond the Trent, was required
to raise and arm his
men and tenants to resist the Scots.(82)