MarginaliaProposition.THe body of Christ in the Sacrament is not made of bread, but is made present of bread, pag. 89. lin. 9. &c. and pag. 228. lin. 44.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradictiō.Of bread is made the body of Christ, pag. 388. lin. 12.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
The catholicke fayth hath from the beginning confessed truly Christes intent to make bread hys body, pag. 29. lin. 2.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
And of many breades is made one body of Christ. pag 165. lin. 2.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
And fayth sheweth mee, that breade is the body of Christ, that is to say, made the body of Christ, pag. 333. lin. 23. 25.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Christ gaue that he made of bread, pag. 292. lin. 34.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia2. Proposition.Christ spake plainly: This is my body, makyng demonstration of the bread, when he sayd: This is my body.
This is taken from Stephen Gardiner, A detection of the devils sophistrie (London: 1546), STC 11591.
MarginaliaContradiction.The demonstration [This] may be referred to the inuisible substaunce, pag. 120. lin. 41.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
The verbe [Is] was of hys body and of his bloud, and not of the bread and wyne, pag. 284. lin. 43.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Illis verbis [Hoc est corpus meum] substantia corporis significàtur, nec de pane quicquam intelligitur, quando corpus de substantia sua, non aliena prædicetur.
Illis verbis (Hoc est corpus meum) substantia corporis significatur, nec de pane quicquam intelligitur, quando corpus de substantia sua, non aliena predicetur. Not translated. By these words (this is my body) is meant the substance of the body, nor is anything understood concerning bread when the body is announced as being of its own substance, not of another's (??) [Unable to find in Migne.]
This quotation is taken from Marcus Antonius [Stephen Gardiner], Confutation Cavillationem (Paris: 1552).
Marginalia3. Proposition.When CHRIST sayd: This is my body, the truth of the literal sense hath an absurdity in carnall reason. pag. 157. lin. 34.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.What can bee more euidently spoken of the presence of CHRISTES naturall body and bloud in the most blessed Sacrament of the aultar, then is in these wordes: This is my body.
This is taken from Stephen Gardiner, A detection of the devils sophistrie (London: 1546), STC 11591.
Marginalia4. Proposition.Where the body of CHRIST is, there is whole CHRIST God and man: and when we speake of CHRISTES body, we must vnderstand a true body which hath both forme & quantity. pag. 81. lin. 5. Mar. An. obiect. 77. Smith fol. 105.
These quotations are taken from Richard Smith, A confutation of a certain booke (Paris: 1550?), STC 22819 and Marcus Antonius [Stephen Gardiner], Confutatio Cavillationem (Paris: 1552).
And he is present in the sacrament as he is in heauen. pag. 161. lin. 4. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
We beleue simply the substaunce of CHRISTES body to be in the Sacrament without drawing away of the accidences or adding. pag. 397. lin. 43.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.CHRIST is not present in the Sacrament after the maner of quantity, but vnder the forme and quantity of bread and wyne. pag. 81. lin. 89. and pag. 101. lin. 22.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia5. Proposition.In such as receiue the Sacrament worthely, CHRIST dwelleth corporally, and naturally, & carnally. pag. 190. lin. 7. pag. 197. lin. 27. pag. 217. lin. 10.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradictiō.The maner of CHRISTES being in the Sacrament is not corporall, not carnall, not naturall, not sensible, not perceptible: but onely spirituall pag. 181. lin. 18. &c. & lin. 25. & pag. 223. lin. 21.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia6. Proposition.We receiue CHRIST in the Sacrament of his flesh and bloud, if we receaue him worthely, pag. 190. lin. 7. pag. 197. lin. 27.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
When an vnrepentant sinner receaueth the Sacrament, he hath not CHRISTES body within him pag. 256. lin. 18.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
He that eateth verely the flesh of CHRIST, is by nature in CHRIST, and CHRIST is naturally in hym. pag. 18. lin. 51.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradictiō.An euill man in the Sacrament receaueth in deede CHRISTES very body. pag. 18. lin. 24. 25.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Euill men eat verely the flesh of CHRIST. pag. 256. lin. 24. 25. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia7. Proposition.CHRIST geueth vs to be eaten the same fleshe that he toke of the Virgin Mary. pag. 274. lin. 25.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradictiō.We receiue not in the Sacrament CHRISTES flesh that was crucified. pag. 276. lin. 1.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia8. Proposition.Saint Augustines rule in hys booke De doctrina Christiana, pertayneth not to CHRISTES supper. pag. 132. lin. 40.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Saint Augustine meaneth of the Sacrament. Ibidem. and pag. 10. lin. 44.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia9. Proposition.Reason in place of seruice (as being inferiour to faith) will agree with the fayth of transubstantiation well ynough. pag. 300. lin. 12.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
And as reason receiued into faithes seruice doth not striue with transubstantiation, but agreeth well with it: so mans senses be no such direct aduersaries to transubstantiation, as a matter wherof they can not skyll: for the senses can not skill of substances. pag. 307. lin. 11. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Thyne eyes say there is but bread and wyne, thy tast sayth the same, thy feeling and smelling agree fully with them. Hereunto is added the carnall mans vnderstanding, which because it taketh the beginning of the
senses, proceedeth in reasoning sensually. In the deuils Sophistry. fol. 6.
This is taken from Stephen Gardiner, A detection of the devils sophistrie (London: 1546), STC 11591.
The Church hath not forborne to preach the truth, to the confusion of mans senses and vnderstanding. fol. 15.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia10. PropositionIt is called bread, because of the outward visible matter, pag. 327. lin. [illegible text]
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.When it is called bread, it is ment CHRIST the spirituall bread, pag 320. lin 41.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia11. Proposition.And the catholicke faith teacheth that the fraction is in the outward signe, and not in the body of CHRIST, pag. 165. lin. 9. and pag. 392. lin. 42.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.That which is broken is the body of CHRIST, pag. 392. lin. 49.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia12. Proposition.The inward nature of the bread is the substance, pag. 323. lin. 14.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Substance signifieth in Theodoret (he sayth) the outward nature, pag. 404. lin. 40.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia13. Proposition.The substances of bread & wyne be visible creatures, pag. 322. lin. 30. and. 323. lin. 32.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Accidences be the visible natures and visible elemēts. pag. 406. lin. 16. and 25. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia14. Proposition.CHRIST is our satisfaction wholy and fully, & hath payed our whole debt to God the father for the appeasing of his wrath against vs, pag. 92. lin. 6. 7.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.The act of the Priest done according to Gods cōmaūdement must nedes be propitiatory, and ought to be trusted on, to haue a propitiatory effect, pag. 437. lin. 13.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia15. Proposition.The sacrifice of our Sauiour CHRIST was neuer reiterate, pag. 416. lin. 8.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Priests do sacrifice CHRIST, pag. 431. lin. 16. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
And the catholicke doctrine teacheth the dayly sacrifice to be the same in essence that was offred on þe crosse. pag. 439. lin. 11.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia16. Proposition.The Nestorians graunted both the Godhead & māhead alwaies to be in Christ cōtinually, pag. 348. lin. 11. 12.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.The Nestorians denied CHRIST conceiued God, or born God, but that he was afterward God, as a man that is not borne a bishop, is after made Bishop. So the Nestorians sayd that the Godhead was an accessiō after by merite, and that he was conceiued onely man. pag. 347. lin. 47. 50. 51. and pag. 148. lin. 47.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia17. Proposition.CHRIST vseth vs familiarly as he did his Apostles, pag. 93. lin. 21.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.CHRIST is not to be sayd conuersant in earth, pag. 114. lin. 11. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaNotes declaring wherein Winchest. graunted to the spirituall vse of the Sacrament.CHRIST declared eating of him selfe to signify beleuing, pag. 29. lin. antepenultima.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
CHRIST must be spiritually in a man, before he receaue the sacramēt, or els he cā not receaue the sacramēt worthely, pag. 54. lin. 44. pag. 160. lin. vltima, pag. 196. lin. 3. pag. 205. lin. 32.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
How CHRIST is present, pag. 69. lin. 29. &c. pag. 81. lin. 12. pag. 181. lin. 26. pag. 65. lin. 15.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
By faith we know onely the being present of CHRISTES most precious body, not the maner thereof, pag. 70. lin. 15.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
When we speake of CHRISTES body, we must vnderstand a true body, which hath both fourme and quantitie, pag. 81. lin. 5. lin. 35.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Although CHRISTES body haue all those truthes of fourme and quantitie: yet it is not present after the maner of quantitie, ibidem, lin. 8. 9.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
The demonstratiue [this] may bee referred to the inuisible substance, pag. 120. lin. 42.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Al the old praiers and ceremonies soūd, as though the people did communicate with the Priest, pag. 165. lin. 46.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
The maner of CHRISTES being in the Sacrament is not corporall, not carnall, not naturall, not sensible, not perceptible, but onely spirituall, pag. 181. lin. 19. &c. lin. 25. pag. 223. lin. 21.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
When an vnrepentant synner receiueth the sacramēt, he hath not Christes body within him, pag. 256. lin. 18.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
We eate not CHRIST as he sitteth in heauen raigning pag. 276. lin. 18.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
The word [Transubstantiation] was first spoken of in a generall Coūcell, where the bishop of Rome was present, pag. 284. lin. 11.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
In the sacrifice of the church CHRISTES death is not iterated, but a memory dayly renued of that death: So as CHRISTES offering on the Crosse once done & cōsummate, is now onely remembred, pag. 440. lin. 40. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.