The fact that the scriptural reference in the gloss 'Astiterunt reges terræ, & principes conuenerunt in vnum aduersus Dominum & Christum eius' is given in Latin is probably because it opposes royal intentions and God in such a stark way; if so, this tells us something about what Foxe felt should be kept from vulgar eyes and ears (however, it would be simple enough to follow up the reference in an English Bible).
[Back to Top]MarginaliaThe power of this world set against Christ.And their Maiesties by thys Proclamation geue full power and authoritie to all Byshops and Ordinaries, and all Iustices of peace, Maiors, Shiriffes, Bayliffes of Cities and Townes corporate, and other head Officers within this Realme and the dominions thereof, and expresly commaundeth and willeth the same and euery of them, that they and euery of them within their seuerall limites and iurisdictions, shall in the default and negligence of the sayd Subiectes, after the sayde fiftene dayes expired, enquire and searche out the sayd bookes, writynges, and workes, and for this purpose enter into the house or houses, closettes, and secrete places of euery person, of what so euer degree, beyng negligent in this behalfe, and suspected to keepe any such booke, writyng, or workes, contrary to this Proclamation: And that the sayd Iustices, Maiors, Sheriffes, Bailiffes, and other head Officers aboue specified, and euery of them within their sayd limites and iurisdictions, findyng any of the sayd subiectes negligent and faulty in thys behalfe, shall commit euery such offender to Ward, there to remaine with out bayle or maynprise, till the same offender or offenders haue receiued such punishment, as the sayd Statute doth li-
[Back to Top]mite and appoint in this behalfe. Geuen vnder our Signes Manuell, at our Honor of Hampton court, the. xiij. daye of Iune, the fyrst and second yeares of our raignes.
¶ Imprinted by Iohn Cawod. Anno. 1555.
Foxe almost certainly printed these articles from a copy in Bonner's records. The inquiries were duly made among the London companies and copies of banned books were found among members of the draper's company. (See Brigden, p. 595).
MarginaliaArticles to be Inquired vppon.1 WHether they haue sene any of the foresayd bookes.
2 Whether they haue heard of any of the sayd bookes.
3 Where they were, & in what place they haue sene thē.
4 Whom they know to haue lately come frō beyond the sea, especially from Zurike, Strausbrough, Frankforde, Wezel Emden, and Disburge.
5 Whom they know, or vehemently suspect to be common cariers of letters or money thether from hence.
6 That they bryng to my Lord Maior all such seditious bookes as they haue, or shall haue found hereafter.
This section may be compared with the reproduction of the 'Rubric of the Mass' in Book X: as on the earlier occasion, the glosses constitute a running attack based on interlinked themes against the content of catholic devotion. In contrast to the glosses next to the rubric of the mass, the tone here is less varied: there is nothing like the mocking of the arbitrariness of the mass found in book X. The reason for this difference is that the subject is not so much a pointless if insulting ritual, but the place of Mary in the Christian scheme, and so the glosses seek, firmly but without mockery, to put her in a more modest position than that accorded to her by the catholic texts criticised. The organising principle of the critique is the divine hierarchy, and many of the glosses point out that the primer and psalter contain ideas which displace God and (especially) Christ from their places in that hierarchy ('One mediatour betwene God and men, the man Iesus Christ'; 'Wrong mediation'; 'The office of Christ geuen to our Lady'; 'If Maryes merites might helpe vs, then Christ dyed in vayne'; 'Treason agaynst Christes person and dignitye'; 'All iudgement is geuē to Christ alone, and before him the virgin also her self shalbe iudged'; 'If our Lady be all in all then God belyke sitteth idle in heauen';' O impious blasphemye'; 'If Mary forgeue sinnes, then is our fayth in Christ in vayne'; 'The Deuill and the Pope sayth so and not God'; 'Mary made a commaunder of Christ'; 'Christ made a captiue and a prisoner in the Popes Church'; 'Our Lady made equall with God in the Church Rome'). One consequence of the misdirection of devotion is that it does the misdirector no spiritual good, and various glosses point out the vain or false nature of the devotional formulations they lie next to ('False merite'; 'Vayne trust'; 'Wrong inuocation'; 'False trust'). As with the critique of the mass in Book X, such a misdirection of effort is not merely useless, it is also dangerous because it constitutes an insult to God, or blasphemy ('Horrible blasphemye and derogation to Christes bloud'; 'Derogation of the Crosse of Christ'; 'Derogation of Christes passion'; 'Horrible blasphemy agaynst the Lord'), and furthermore it invests objects and subjects with a spiritual significance they do not deserve, which is idolatry ('Idolatrye to the material Crosse'; 'Blasphemous Idolatrye'; 'Manifest Idolatrye'; 'Idolatrye of the cloysterers'; 'These wordes stincke of blasphemous Idolatrye'; 'The Church of Rome conuict of manifest idolatry'). Thus, Foxe's critique works through a few intertwined points which he makes again and again.
[Back to Top]The entire section on the passages on the Virgin Mary in the Sarum missal and the Psalter of Our Lady first appears in the 1570 edition. It takes as its logical starting point the previous section on the Marian government's attempts to ban seditious and heretical literature. Here Foxe is contrasting the literature which the Marian church championed with the literature it banned. This section is less of anattack on the cult of the Virgin Mary per se, than an attack on the popular Wayland primers which contained the versions of the Sarum primer quoted by Foxe. The Wayland primers were sponsored by the Marian government and were a popular and effective means of disseminating a Christocentric catholic piety to lay people (see Duffy, pp. 526-27, 538-39 and 542-43). Foxe sought to undermine the Wayland primers, partly through misquotation and partly through linking them to the Psalter of Our Lady, a thirteenth-century work which was attributed to St Bonaventure. The theology of the Psalter of Our Lady was sufficiently distinct from that of the catholic reformation to cause embarrassment. And Foxe was ready to alter the passages he was quoting to achieve the desired result. (For Foxe's polemical objectives in printing this section see Freeman [2004]).
[Back to Top]This section is a very revealing example of how clever and ruthless a propagandist Foxe could be.
Foxe is quoting from one of the primer (book for the instruction of children) printed by John Wayland. These works were sponsored by Mary's government (see Duffy, pp. 526-27 and 538-39). It should be cautioned that Foxe's quotations from the primer are not always accurate (for details see Freeman [2004]).
[Back to Top]Holy Mary: mother most pure of virgines all: Mother and daughter of the kyng celestiall: So comfort vs in our desolation: That by thy prayer and speciall meditation, we enioy the reward of the heauenly reigne. &c.
Conferre this with the Scriptures, good reader, and iudge vprightly whether this doctrine be tolerable in the Church or not.
It followeth more in the second Lesson.
Holy Mary of all godly the godlyest.
Pray for vs of all holy the holyest.
That he our prayers accept may in good wise.
which of thee was borne and reigneth aboue skies. &c.
In the thyrd Lesson.
Thy sonne besech with humble intercession,
To purge vs cleane of our Transgression,
That so beyng redemed we may the place ascende
where thou dwellest with him world without end.
The Versicle.
Pray for the people, entreat for the Clergie, Marginalia>One mediatour betwene God and men, the man Iesus Christ.make entercession for the deuout womankynd: let all feele thy helpe that worthely solemnise thy memoriall. &c.
An other Versicle.
Holy mother of God make thy petition: that we may MarginaliaFalse meritedeserue Christes promission. &c.
And in the Antheme after Benedictus, thus it foloweth.
We besech thee of thy pitie to haue vs in remembraūce, and to make meanes for vs vnto Christ, that we being supported by thy helpe, may deserue to attayne the kingdōe of heauē.
Furthermore in the Collect after it foloweth.
And graunt that MarginaliaWrong mediation.through the gracious intercession of the virgine thy mother, we may bee deliuered from this present heuynes, and haue the fruition of eternall gladnes.
It foloweth moreouer in the sayd Primer thus, concernyng the materiall Crosse.
O God whiche haste ascended thy most holy Crosse, and hast giuen lyght to the darkenes of the world, MarginaliaIdolatrie to the materiall crosse.vouchsafe by the vertue of thy Crosse: to illumine, visite, and comfort both our hartes and bodies. &c.
Moreouer, in þe name of s. Iohn Baptist thus it prayeth.