MarginaliaAnno. 1555. October.Other saie cleane cōtrary. Thomas part. 3 q. 8. art. 3. hoc derogat [inquit] veritati corporis Christi.
hoc derogat (inquit) veritati corporis Christi. Not translated. this detracts (he says) from the truth of the body of Christ
William Peryn, Three godlye and notable sermons of the Sacramente (London: 1546), STC 19785.5.
M. Sentiarum. Qui dicit corpus Christi non posse a mure manducari aut a bruto
Not translated.
Who says that the body of Christ cannot be eaten by a mouse or by an animal
[Unable to locate in Migne]
Marginalia11.MarginaliaA mouse may eate Christes body, sayth the Maister of Sentence.Winchester saith that an vnrepētant sinner receiuyng the Sacrament, hath not Christes body nor spirite within hym. pag. 256. lin. 18. 25. 26.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
This quotation is taken from Richard Smith, A confutation of a certain booke (Paris: 1550), STC 22819.
Marginalia12.MarginaliaA mouse can not eate it saith Winchester.Winchester saith, that of the figure it maie not bee saied: Adore it, worship it: and that is not to be adored whiche the bodily eye seeth. pag. 202. lin. 38. pag. 272. lin. 6. Marc. Ant. fol. 175. fac. 2.
This quotation is taken from Marcus Antonius [Stephen Gardiner], Confutation Cavillationem (Paris: 1552).
Docetur populus non adorare quod vident oculis corporis
And that is not to be adored which the bodely eye seeth.
[Not completely translated]
The people are taught not to worship what they see with the eyes of the body
[Is thisDe Vera Obedientia?]
This quotation is taken from Richard Smith, A confutation of a certain booke (Paris: 1550), STC 22819.
Marginalia13.MarginaliaWithin hym, that is, within his soule.Winchester saieth, that reason will agree with the doctrine of Transubstantiation well enough page. 30. lin. 12.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
This quotation is taken from Richard Smith, A confutation of a certain booke (Paris: 1550), STC 22819.
Marginalia14.Other saie that wormes in the sacrament be gēdred of accidences. Ex speciebus Sacramentalibus generātur vermes.
Ex speciebus Sacramentalibus generantur vermes Other saie that wormes in the sacrament be gendred of accidences [Not completely translated] ??
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia15.Winchester saith that the accidences of bread and wine do mould, sower, and waxe vineger, pa. 300. lin. 24. and pa. 400. lin. 6.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Not given in1576.
But he aunswereth so confusely, that the Reader can not vnderstand him, be he neuer so attentiue.
[Unusually, Foxe does not give the Latin which he had done in1563]
This quotation is taken from Richard Smith, A confutation of a certain booke (Paris: 1550), STC 22819.
Marginalia16.Winchester saieth: euery yea containeth a naie, in it naturally: So as who soeuer saieth, this is breade, saieth it is no wine. For in the rule of common reason the graunt of one substaūce, is the deniall of an other. And therefore reason hath these conclusions throughly: whatsoeuer is bread, is no wine, whatsoeuer is wine, is no milke, and so forthe. So Christe saiyng: This is my body, saith it is no bread, pag. 291. lin. 22. and pa. 300. lin. 17.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
This quotation is taken from Richard Smith, A confutation of a certain booke (Paris: 1550), STC 22819.
Marginalia17.MarginaliaThe Masse taketh his satisfaction by the deuotion of the Priest & people, and not of the thing offered.Other saie, that the Masse is a sacrifice satisfactory by deuotion of the priest, & of them for whō it is offred, and not by þe thing that is offered. Thom. part. 3. 9. 79. art. 5. Winchester saieth otherwise, pag. 92. lin. 5.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia18.Winchester saieth, that the onely immolation of Christe in hym self vpon the aultar of the crosse, is the very satisfactorie sacrifice for the reconciliation of mākinde, vnto the fauour of God, pag. 437. lin. 31.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
This quotation is taken from Richard Smith, A confutation of a certain booke (Paris: 1550), STC 22819.
Marginalia1. Proposition.THe body of Christ in the Sacrament is not made of bread, but is made present of bread, pag. 89. lin. 9. &c. and pag. 228. lin. 44.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Of bread is made the body of Christ, pag. 388. li. 12.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
The catholicke faith hath from the beginnyng cōfessed truely Christes intent, to make bread his bodie, pag. 29. line. 2.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
And of many breades is made one body of Christ. pag 167. lin. 2.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
And faithe sheweth me, that breade is the bodie of Christ, that is to saie, made the body of Christ, pa. 333. lin. 23. 25,
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Christ gaue that he made of bread, pag. 292. lin. 34.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia2. Proposition.Christe spake plainly: This is my bodie, makyng demonstration of the bread, when he saied: This is my body. In the deuils Sophistrie. 27.
This is taken from Stephen Gardiner, A detection of the devils sophistrie (London: 1546), STC 11591.
MarginaliaContradiction.The demonstration (This) maie be referred to the
inuisible substaunce, pag. 120. lin. 41.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
The verbe (is) was of his body and of his bloude, and not of the bread and wine, pag. 284. lin. 43.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Illis verbis (Hoc est corpus meum) substantia corporis significatur, nec de pane quicquam intelligitur, quādo corpus de substantia sua, non aliena prædicetur.
Illis verbis (Hoc est corpus meum) substantia corporis significatur, nec de pane quicquam intelligitur, quando corpus de substantia sua, non aliena predicetur. Not translated. By these words (this is my body) is meant the substance of the body, nor is anything understood concerning bread when the body is announced as being of its own substance, not of another’s (??) [Unable to find in Migne.]
This quotation is taken from Marcus Antonius [Stephen Gardiner], Confutation Cavillationem (Paris: 1552).
Marginalia3. Proposition.When Christe saied: This is my bodie, the truthe of the literall sense hath an absurditie in carnall reason. pag. 157. lin. 34.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.What cā be more euidently spoken, of the presence of Christes naturall bodie and bloud, in the most blessed Sacrament of the aultar, then is in these wordes: This is my bodie. In the deuils Sophistrie. fol. 51.
This is taken from Stephen Gardiner, A detection of the devils sophistrie (London: 1546), STC 11591.
Marginalia4. Proposition.Where the body of Christ is, there is whole Christ God & man, and when we speake of Christes body, we must vnderstand a true body, which hath both forme & quantitie. pag. 81. lin. 5. Mar. Ant. obiect. 77. Smith fo. 105.
These quotations are taken from Richard Smith, A confutation of a certain booke (Paris: 1550?), STC 22819 and Marcus Antonius [Stephen Gardiner], Confutatio Cavillationem (Paris: 1552).
And he is presente in the Sacramente, as he is in heauen. pag. 161. lin. 4. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
We beleue simply the substaunce of Christes body to be in the Sacrament without drawing awaie of the accidences or addyng. pag. 397. lin. 41.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Christe is not present in the Sacrament, after the maner of quantitie, but vnder the forme and quanities of bread and wine. pag. 81. lin. 89. and pag. 101. lin. 22.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia5. Proposition.In such as receiue the Sacramēt worthely, Christ dwelleth corporally, and naturally, and carnally. pag. 190. lin. 7. pag. 197. lin. 27. pag. 217. lin. 10.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.The maner of Christes beyng in the Sacramente is not corporall, not carnall, not naturall, not sensible, not perceptible: but onely spirituall, pag. 181. lin. 18. &c. and line 25. pag. 223. line 21.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia6. Proposition.We receiue Christ in the Sacramente of his fleshe and bloud, if we receiue hym worthely, page. 190. line 7. pag. 197. line 27.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
When an vnrepentaunt synner receiueth the Sacrament, he hath not Christes body within hym, pa. 256 line 18.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
He that eateth verely the fleshe of Christe, is by nature in Christ, and Christ is naturally in hym. pag. 18. line 51.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.An euill man in the Sacrament receiueth in deede Christes very bodie. pag. 18. line 24. 25.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Euill men eate verely the fleshe of Christ, pag. 2561. line 24. 25. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia7. Proposition.Christ giueth vs to be eaten the same fleshe that he tooke of the virgine Marie, pag. 274. line 25.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.We receiue not in the Sacrament Christes fleshe that was crucified. pag. 276. line 1.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia8. Proposition.S. Augustines rule in his boke De doctrina Christiana, pertaineth not to Christes supper. pag. 132. lin. 40.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Saincte Augustine meaneth of the Sacramente, ibidem, and pag. 10. line 44.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia9. Proposition.Reason in place of seruice (as beeyng inferiour to faithe) will agree with the faithe of Transubstantiation well enough. pag. 300. line 12.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
And as reason receiued into faithes seruice, doeth not striue wt transubstantiation, but agreeth well with it: so mans senses be no suche direct aduersaries to trāsubstantiatiō, as a matter wherof thei can not skill: for the senses cannot skill of substances. pag. 307. lin. 11. &c.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Thine eyes say there is but bread and wine, thy tast saith the same, thy felyng & smellyng agree fully wt thē. Hereunto is added the carnall mans vnderstandyng, which because it taketh þe beginning of þe senses, procedeth in reasoning sēsually. In þe deuils Sophistry. fo. 6.
This is taken from Stephen Gardiner, A detection of the devils sophistrie (London: 1546), STC 11591.
The Churche hath not forborne to preache the truthe, to the confusion of mannes senses and vnderstandyng. fol. 15.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia10. Proposition.It is called bread, because of the outwarde visible matter, pag. 327. line.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.When it is called bread, it is ment Christ the spirituall bread, pag 320. line 41.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia11. Proposition.And the catholicke faithe teacheth, that the fractiō is in the outward signe, and not in the bodie of Christ, pag. 165. line 9. and pag. 392. line 42.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.That whiche is broken is the body of Christ, pag. 392. line 49.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
Marginalia12. Proposition.The inwarde nature of the bread is the substance, pag. 323. line 14.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
MarginaliaContradiction.Substaunce signifieth in Theodoret (he saith) the outward nature, pag. 404. line 40.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.
The substaunces of breade and wine bee visible creatures, pag. 322. line 30. and. 323. line 32.
This quotation is taken from Stephen Gardiner, An explication and assertion of the true catholique faith (Rouen: 1551), STC 11592.